December 2009

S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Tags

Powered by InsaneJournal

Hopefully my last Twilight post

I've pretty much moved beyond thinking about Twilight unless someone tries to sell it to me, but this post really hits home on so much of the bigger issue.

They seek out books that reflect gender roles because we teach them from birth that women and men are opposites and can only function when divided into separate boxes. They adore these roles because our media tells them exactly what they need to look like, be like, and act like. People like to laugh when I tell them that our media is teaching young girls that they should grow up to be saved by men, and then I point out shit like Twilight. Throughout the entire series, Bella doesn't do a damn thing for herself. Meanwhile, Edward controls her, operantly conditions her be with him, renders her utterly dependent on him, and Meyer portrays this as love. Teenage girls think this is love.


If I didn't see this every time I hear people talk about these books, every time people insult other female characters simply because they have a vagina, I would simply dismiss the Twilight series. Bad writing. Uninteresting characters. That's all; not even worth the time it takes to think about it. But it's a symptom of something else, and that something can manifest in a hideous way.

It's natural to obsess over a partner in a new relationship and part of the process. It's self-serving, because we constantly think about them, constantly want to be with them, which protects and promotes the relationship. This is fine, in and of itself. Where it becomes dangerous is when we combine this obsession with gender roles and effectively give the male-identified individual in the relationship more power than the female-identified individual.

We teach girls to obsess, to focus all their energy on being in a relationship. We. Teach. Them. We do this to them, we tell them that this is who they should be. And we tell them over and over and over again. Obsession might not be inherently negative, but when a girl/woman trades in her identity and free choice for a boy/man's and does so because society has been telling her she should since could walk, we have a gender-based problem.

Comments